Cloned Pop Star Generates Ethics Debate SAN FRANCISCO - The cloned-to-order pop star Ashlee Simpson, a 20-year-old with three hit CDs to her name, has reignited a fierce ethical and scientific debate over cloning technology.
Ashlee cost Geffen Music $50,000 and was created from DNA from her “sister,” singer Jessica Simpson, co-host of the popular Nick & Jessica Variety Hour on ABC.
"She is identical. Her personality is the same," her owner, Geffen Music, said in a telephone interview. “We just dyed her hair black and used a different singer to record her songs.”
Scientists warn that cloning is still a very inexact science. It takes many gruesome failures to produce just a single clone. In 1990, Sony Records created Jamie Lynn Spears, a singing “little sister” for Britney Spears, but her CD sales were disappointing and the project was terminated.
Several research teams around the world, meanwhile, are racing to create the first cloned monkey.
The company that created Ashlee, Sausalito-based Genetic Savings and Clone, said it hopes by May to have produced two more platinum-selling pop stars for various labels. If they are successful, the company plans to create a cloned Crossover Artist using DNA from the exhumed body of Selena.
"It's morally problematic and a little reprehensible," said David Mavnus, co-director of the Center for Biomedical Ethics at Stanford University. "Ashlee Simpson may have Jessica’s DNA, but she doesn’t have any of her sparkle.”
Critics also complain that the technology is available only to the wealthy, and that everyone should be able to afford to have their own clone of Britney Spears or Avril Lavigne.
Sociologists argue that most families already do.
"The thing that many people do not realize is that the cloned singer is not the same as the original," said Bonnie Beamer, a Texas A&M animal behaviorist. "She may wear the same whorish outfits and sing the same kind of tripe, but on the inside, she has completely different set of banal thoughts and feelings.”
Between 15 percent and 45 percent of cloned pop stars die within the first 30 days, Beamer noted.
Jamie Lynn in her Sunday Best